Kates Estate – Decision of Justice Gans

Blog – Kates Estate – Decision of Justice Gans – 18 November 2020 

Yesterday Justice Gans released his decision in the Kates Estate.  A hard fought case heard over 9 days in September and October.

In his usual edifying choice of words Justice Gans, in particular, had the opportunity to put into practice what he has called “hot-tubbing” a process that he has been advocating for  many years and more recently in the context of the pandemic (See Arthur Gans, “Litigating in the time of COVID-19: Try Hot-tubbing … While Keeping a Safe Distance” (2020) 39:2 Adv J 37)).

This hot-tubbing process is putting together a collaborative process for the experts witnesses to discuss and review critically the evidence – rather than serving as adversarial messengers for the parties.  Justice Gans ordered this process as in his words “he had some measure of difficulty understanding how much weight could be given to a retrospective analysis of testamentary capacity, even by skilled psychiatrists, who had to form their opinions based on the reports of others, which may or may not have been fulsome, complete or accurate at first instance.”

The process means getting the experts hired for the benefit of the court to work together (ie discuss their various viewpoints) to provide focussed evidence to assist the trier of fact and to collaborate in its presentation.  In this particular case, a “Collaborative Letter” was created by counsel together for the purpose of the experts, in this case Drs. Richard Shulman and Ken Shulman (no relation). 

During their “hot-tubbing” together Drs. Shulman debated the facts, law and medical evidence and theories to, together, provide a more fulsome analysis.  This process does not necessarily result in a change of opinion by the expert but provides a greater sense of independence and neutrality that the expert evidence process desperately needs in our litigation system.

Although used for the first time in an estate litigation case, this concept equally applies to any case where competing expert evidence is being relied upon.

This case represents a fundamental shift in mind-set for the judicial, counsel and client litigation experience which is very much welcomed in an age where cases tend to focus on the one upmanship and superficialness of getting a case done.

Related Posts

Passing of Accounts and Estate Accounting

Passing of Accounts Estate Trustees are required to keep accurate and up-to-date accounts of the estate or trusts they are administering. Obtaining the court’s approval of these accounts is a process known as “passing of accounts”. The court’s approval is not always required, but in certain circumstances a passing of accounts is necessary. These instances

Read More »

Intestacy

DYING WITHOUT A WILL; INTESTACY LAWS IN ONTARIO  In accordance with the Succession Law Reform Act (SLRA), when you die without a Will (known as dying intestate) your estate will be administered according to the law of intestacy. The Rules The rules of intestacy are inflexible, and apply regardless based on bloodlines. These rules may

Read More »

Estate Information Return

What are the consequences for NOT filing with the Minister of Finance? Estate representatives who fail to file the Information Return as required, or who make false or misleading statements on the return, are guilty of an offence and, on conviction, are liable to a fine of at least $1,000 and up to twice the

Read More »

World Elder Abuse Awareness Day (WEADD)

Financial abuse is the most common abuse of elder abuse and is the use of a person’s money in a fraudulent way and without their consent or awareness. The Canadian Securities Administrators is launching a campaign this month, which is aimed at family, friends and caregivers of older adults. People are being encouraged to reach

Read More »

Making a Will

What is a Will? A Will is a legally binding declaration of a person’s wishes regarding the disposition of his or her estate after death. Typically, a Will includes clauses such as: identification of the person making the Will; revocation of all previous Wills; appointment of executors and guardians; payment of debts and taxes; specific

Read More »

Your Rights as a Patient

As Canadians age and the need for health care increases, it is invaluable to be aware of your rights as a patient to ensure you make informed decisions about medical treatment decisions. Right to Information on All Treatment Options Also known as the Right of Informed Consent, your doctor is required to inform you of

Read More »
Scroll to Top